- 2022 – Avid Golfer Caggy Awards:
- Best Mountain Golf Course
- Best Apres Golf
- 3rd for Best Conditions
- 3rd for Best Service
- 2021,20,19,18 & 17: Best in Grand County
- 2021 – CAGGY Awards: Best Mountain Golf Course
- 2020 – Colorado Avid Golfer: Best Mountain Golf Course: Colorado Avid Golfer people’s choice award
- 2019 – Golf Advisor: #1 Mountain Golf Course
- 2019 – Golf Advisor: Pole Creek is named 44th in the nation
- 2018 – Golf Advisor: #1 Mountain Golf Course
- 2017 – Golf Advisor: Pole Creek top 50 in the Nation # 1 Mountain Golf Course in Colorado
- 2017 – Golf Advisor: #1 for Colorado Golf Advisor and #28 in the Nation
- 2016 – Golf Advisor: #1 for Colorado Golf Advisor
- 2016 – Colorado Avid Golfer Magazine: Best Mountain Golf Course
- 2016 & 2015 – Golf Advisor: #1 Mountain Golf Course in Colorado
- 2015 – Colorado Avid Golfer Magazine:
- Best Mountain Golf Course
- 3rd for Best Views
- 3rd for Best Wildlife
- 2014 – Colorado Avid Golfer Magazine:
- Best Mountain golf Course
- 2nd for Best Views
- 3rd for Best Apres Golf
- 2013 – Colorado Avid Golfer Magazine: Best Mountain Golf Course February 2013.
- 2007/08 – Zagat Survey: Excellent Rating
- 2006 – Zagat Survey: Best course to play in the Rocky Mountain Region including CO, ID, MT, NV, UT & WY.
- 2005 – Avid Golfer Magazine:
- 5th best course to bring out of town guests
- Best Finishing hole #9 Ridge
- 2nd Place – Best Public Mountain Course
- 3rd Place – Best Golf Course in the $50-$99 range
- 4th Place – Most Scenic Course (public or Resort)
- 3rd Place – Most underrated Golf Course (public or resort)
- 2004 – Denver Post, Colorado Peaks: Best Mountain Golf Course
- 2003 – Rocky Mountain News: Top Mountain Golf Course – Top of the Rockies Award
- 1995 – Golf Digest: America’s 500 best places you can play – Colorado #1 Pole Creek
- 1990 – Golf Digest: America’s Best 75 Public Golf Courses Pole Creek rated in the top 75
- 1988 – Golf Digest: America’s Best 75 Public Golf Courses Pole Creek rated in the top 50
- 1985 – Golf Digest: Best New Public Golf Course
